Knowing how to choose a 3PL is one of the first operational decisions a consumer brand makes in the United States, and one of the hardest to reverse. Your third-party logistics provider stores your inventory, ships your orders and, in retail, decides whether your purchase orders arrive on time and compliant. A poor fit shows up later as chargebacks, stockouts and a warehouse move in the middle of your busiest season.
Brand Refinery is a CPG consulting firm that helps consumer brands build the supply chain, pricing and retail strategy needed to launch and scale in the U.S. market. This guide sets out what a 3PL does, what to check and how to compare providers on equal terms. It is general information, not legal or financial advice; review any logistics contract with a qualified adviser.
What a 3PL is
A 3PL, or third-party logistics provider, is a company that receives, stores, picks, packs and ships products on behalf of a brand. Many also offer kitting, labelling, returns handling, freight management and retailer compliance services. The brand keeps ownership of the inventory; the 3PL provides the building, the labour and the systems.
For an international brand, a 3PL is usually the first physical presence in the United States. It is where the import container lands and where every wholesale and consumer order starts.
When a CPG brand needs a 3PL
You need a 3PL when order volume, channel mix or geography makes self-fulfilment unreliable. Typical triggers are a first retail purchase order, an import program that brings in full pallets or containers, a direct-to-consumer business that has outgrown the founder's garage, or a need for temperature control that you cannot provide yourself.
If you are still deciding between distribution models, read our comparison of 3PL, DSD and warehouse distribution first. This guide assumes you have decided a 3PL is right and need to choose one.
Step 1: Write down your requirements
Before contacting any provider, document what you need. A clear brief produces comparable quotes.
- Product profile: dimensions, weights, units per case, cases per pallet, shelf life and any hazardous or fragile items.
- Storage conditions: ambient, temperature-controlled, refrigerated or frozen.
- Channels: retail and distributor orders by the pallet or case, direct-to-consumer parcels, marketplace replenishment, or a mix.
- Volumes: expected inbound shipments, pallets in storage and orders per month, with seasonal peaks.
- Customers: the retailers and distributors you ship to, since each has its own routing and labelling rules.
- Geography: where your customers and shoppers are, which shapes how many locations you need.
Step 2: Match the 3PL to your channels
Not every 3PL is good at everything. Wholesale and direct-to-consumer fulfilment are different operations.
Retail and distributor fulfilment
Retail orders ship by the case and pallet and must follow each customer's routing guide, with correct pallet configuration, labels, appointment scheduling and advance ship notices. Ask for evidence that the 3PL already ships to your target retailers and distributors, and ask how it handles EDI.
Direct-to-consumer fulfilment
Consumer orders ship as individual parcels. What matters is pick accuracy, order cut-off times, packaging options, carrier rates and integration with your store platform.
Marketplace replenishment
If you sell through Amazon's fulfilment network, your 3PL needs to prepare and label inbound shipments to Amazon's requirements. Our guide on how to sell on Amazon as a CPG brand covers that channel.
A brand with more than one channel should confirm the provider runs each of them at volume today, not that it is willing to try.
Step 3: Check the capabilities that matter for CPG
- Lot and expiration tracking. The warehouse system must record lot codes and expiry dates and ship by first-expired, first-out. Without this you cannot manage a recall or meet retailer shelf-life requirements.
- Food-grade and regulatory status. A facility that holds food for US consumption generally has to be registered with the FDA, and many retailers expect a third-party food safety audit. Ask for the documents. Cosmetics, supplements and alcohol have their own requirements.
- Temperature control. If your product needs it, ask for the temperature ranges, monitoring records and what happens in a power failure.
- Systems and visibility. You should be able to see inventory, orders and receipts in real time, and the system should integrate with your order sources.
- Value-added services. Kitting, relabelling, display building and rework are common needs for imported products and promotions.
- Returns. Know how returns are inspected, restocked or destroyed, and what each step costs.
Step 4: Understand 3PL pricing models
3PL quotes are hard to compare because providers structure fees differently. Most pricing falls into these groups.
- Receiving: charged per pallet, per carton, per container or per hour.
- Storage: charged per pallet, per bin or per cubic foot, usually monthly.
- Pick and pack: charged per order, per line and per unit, with different rates for case and pallet picks.
- Shipping: carrier costs, either passed through or marked up, plus packaging materials.
- Account and technology fees: monthly minimums, system access, integrations and setup.
- Special projects: labelling, kitting and rework, usually charged hourly or per unit.
To compare fairly, build one model. Take a realistic month of your activity and price it through each quote line by line. The cheapest storage rate often belongs to the provider with the highest minimum or the most add-on fees. Feed the result into your landed cost and check it against the margin stack for each channel.
Step 5: Ask the questions that expose weak points
- Which of my target retailers and distributors do you ship to now, and what is your on-time and compliance record with them?
- Who pays when a retailer chargeback is caused by a warehouse error?
- What are your inventory accuracy and order accuracy rates, and how are they measured?
- What is your receiving time from dock to available stock?
- How do you handle peak season capacity, and do you cap volumes?
- What are the monthly minimums, and how do rates change as I grow?
- What does the contract say about liability for damaged or lost inventory, insurance, notice period and exit costs?
- Who is my day-to-day contact, and how are problems escalated?
Ask for references from brands of your size in your category, and call them.
Step 6: Score the shortlist and run a trial
Score each provider against the same criteria: channel fit, CPG capabilities, total cost on your model, location, systems, contract terms and reference quality. Weight the criteria according to what would hurt most if it failed. For a retail-led brand, compliance record usually outweighs a small difference in storage price.
Visit the facility before you sign. Look at housekeeping, how other clients' goods are stored, and whether the team can show you a live order moving through the system. Then start with a controlled first receipt and a small number of orders before sending full inventory.
Location: one warehouse or several
A single well-placed warehouse is simpler and usually enough at launch. Adding locations reduces transit time and parcel cost to consumers but splits inventory and makes forecasting harder. Choose the first location by where your import freight lands and where your largest customers receive, and add a second only when the shipping savings clearly exceed the cost of holding more stock. Good demand forecasting makes that decision far easier.
Common mistakes when choosing a 3PL
- Choosing on storage price alone and ignoring minimums and add-on fees.
- Picking a direct-to-consumer specialist for a retail-led business, or the reverse.
- Skipping the facility visit and the reference calls.
- Signing a long contract without clear service levels or exit terms.
- Sending all inventory before the first orders have shipped correctly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a 3PL do for a CPG brand?
A 3PL receives, stores, picks, packs and ships a brand's products, and often provides kitting, labelling, returns handling and retailer compliance support. The brand keeps ownership of the inventory while the 3PL supplies the warehouse, labour and systems. For international brands it is usually the first physical base in the United States.
How do I compare 3PL pricing?
Compare 3PL pricing by building one model of a realistic month of your activity, including receipts, pallets stored and orders shipped, and pricing it through each quote. Include receiving, storage, pick and pack, shipping, minimums and technology fees. Comparing headline storage rates alone is misleading because fee structures differ.
What should a food brand check before choosing a 3PL?
A food brand should check that the facility is appropriately registered and audited for food storage, that the warehouse system tracks lot codes and expiration dates, and that temperature control and monitoring meet the product's needs. Ask for documents and confirm the provider already ships food products to your target retailers.
Do I need a 3PL that handles EDI and retailer compliance?
If you sell to major retailers or distributors, you need a 3PL that can meet their routing, labelling and electronic document requirements, either directly or through your EDI provider. Warehouse errors on these points lead to chargebacks, so ask for the provider's compliance record with your specific customers and who bears the cost of errors.
Should I use one 3PL warehouse or several?
Most brands should start with one warehouse located near where their freight arrives and their largest customers receive. Additional locations can lower transit time and parcel costs but split inventory and add complexity. Add a second location when shipping savings clearly outweigh the cost of carrying more stock.
Next step
If you are setting up US logistics, Brand Refinery can define your requirements, shortlist providers and build the cost model with you. See our consulting services, then book a strategy call.